Can god create a stone he cannot lift paradox

Author: cvwk

August undefined, 2024

WebThe paradox of the stone asks: Can God create a stone which is so heavy that even he cannot lift it? It seems to show that God is not all-powerful because both answers in regard to the stone end with the same conclusion: God is not omnipotent. WebClassical theists hold that God is omnipotent. But now suppose a critical atheologian were to ask: Can God create a stone so heavy that even he cannot lift it? This is the dilemma of the stone paradox. God either can or cannot create such a stone. Suppose that God can create it. Then there's something he cannot do—namely, lift the stone. Suppose that …

The Rock God Can’t Lift: Actually, It’s NOT Complicated! - NCR

WebThe paradox of omnipotence is commonly exemplified by the riddlelike question that one was told naughty children asked their pastors: whether God can create a stone he cannot lift where he answers in the affirmative, he would be admitting God’s inability to create a stone of certain characteristics, if he answered in the negative he would be ... WebThe God who makes up both the stuff and the rules has no problem at all with your paradox. God can clearly make up a rock that occupies the whole of space. That rock, of course, cannot be moved. The inability to move it is not about power, it is implicit in the definition of space (and of the whole thereof). read easy 5

Omnipotence Paradox - Can God create a stone He cannot lift?

WebFeb 26, 2024 · Does this mean He can accomplish anything? Skeptics often test this notion by offering the following challenge: “Can the all-powerful Christian God create a stone so heavy He cannot lift it?” The question highlights an apparent dilemma: If God cannot create such a stone, or cannot lift what He has created, He is not all-powerful. Web34 views, 4 likes, 2 loves, 0 comments, 0 shares, Facebook Watch Videos from First Presbyterian Church in Philadelphia: Traditional Worship WebA. (1) Either God can create a stone which He cannot lift, or God cannot create a stone which He cannot lift. (2) If God can create a stone which He cannot lift, then God is not omnipotent (since He cannot lift the stone in question). (3) If God cannot create a stone which He cannot lift, then God is not omnipotent (since He cannot create the ... how to stop obsessing on something

Omnipotence paradox Apologetics Wiki Fandom

Omnipotence paradox Solved: Can God create a rock so big that …

WebEither he can't create it, or He can't lift it. It's a paradox. But even the paradox assumes the confinement of omnipotence within logic, as you say. It's only a logical paradox, a paradox in as far as logic is concerned. ... There is no stone that God could create and not "lift," not because God is inherently limited but because the stone is ... WebJoin George and John as they discuss and debate different Philosophical ideas, today they will be looking into the Omnipotence Paradox.The Omnipotence Parado... read easy barnetWebIn the same way if God is infinity and he creates a stone which is infinitely heavy then God can both, lift the stone and cannot lift the stone. The paradox therefore is resolved. … how to stop obsessing over a girl

"WebRussell's paradox is a famous theorem in set theory. It asserts that "the collection of all sets is not a set itself". In the other words "the set of all sets doesn't exist" in the world which … " - Can god create a stone he cannot lift paradox

Can god create a stone he cannot lift paradox

Yang Cui on LinkedIn: "If God were almighty, can he create a stone …

WebIn its form presented before, this paradox presents a problem: if god can create stones of any weight, and lift stones of any weight, how come that is a limitation at all? Let L = set of weights (in Kg) of stones god can lift, and C = set of weights (in Kg) of stones god can create. The theist claim is that L = C = R+. WebIf God can create a rock that He cannot lift, then God is not omnipotent. If God cannot create a rock so heavy that He cannot lift it, then God is not omnipotent. According to …

Did you know?

WebAs such, God could create a stone so heavy that, in one incarnation, he could not lift it, yet could do something that an incarnation that could lift the stone could not. The lifting a rock paradox (Can God lift a stone larger than he can carry?) uses human characteristics to … WebOR if you really want to you can believe that God can do the internally incoherent and therefore can make a stone so big that he cannot lift it and then lift. Internally incoherent you say?... Yes but I believe he can do the internally incoherent. Should not call into question his omnipotence either way. Share Improve this answer Follow

Web-Descartes- he can do logically impossible things so can create and lift stone-Aquinas- cannot do logically impossible things so cannot do both, but doesn't limit his omnipotence-St Augustine- God wouldn't want to, so irrelevant-Peter Geech- doesn't give clear response WebJun 24, 2024 · The most classic example of the paradox, a Morton's fork, is the "Paradox of the Stone": Can an omnipotent being create a stone so heavy that it cannot lift it? If yes: the being's power is limited, because it cannot lift the stone. If no: the being's power is limited, because it cannot create the stone.

Webbut he cannot create any stone that he can't lift. 'God cannot create a stone that God cannot lift means that 'if God can create a stone than he can lift it'. God lacks no … WebOn the other hand, if God cannot create a stone that he cannot lift, then he is also not all-powerful because there is something he cannot do.” — ChatGPT An omnipotent God …

WebHowever, this implies that he is not omnipotent, and so your question is a variation of: The Omnipotence Paradox. The omnipotence paradox, in short, is this: Can God create a stone that he cannot lift? If the answer is "yes," then God will have created something out of his own power to control, therefore no longer being omnipotent.

WebMar 25, 2024 · If God can create such a stone, then He is not all powerful, since He Himself cannot lift it. On the other hand, if He cannot create a stone that cannot be lifted, then He is not all powerful ... read easy 8WebSuppose that God cannot create the stone. Then, again, there's something he cannot do—namely, create it. Either way, God cannot be omnipotent. Among the variety of known theological paradoxes, the paradox of the stone is especially troubling because of … read easy 3WebThe most popular omnipotence paradox goes as follows: can God create a rock so heavy even He can not lift it? Either yes or no, God is not truly omnipotent (according to proponents of this argument). This is unjustified for a few simple reasons. Refutation: The omnipotence paradox utilizes word abuse. read easy book 1 anyflipWebNov 3, 2013 · J.L Cowan attempts to resolve the paradox in "The Paradox of Omnipotence Revisited." He proposes the following: (1) Either God can create a stone which He cannot lift, or He cannot create a stone which He cannot lift. (2) If God can create a stone which He cannot lift, then He is not omnipotent (since He cannot lift the stone in question). how to stop obsessing over a mistakeWebCircular God Counter-paradox. "Paradox of the Stone." There have been many variants of the omnipotence paradox proposed over the past eight hundred years. At the center of these paradoxical questions is the "Stone Paradox" which asks the simple question: "Can god create a stone so heavy that he cannot lift it?" Although numerous philosophers ... how to stop obsessing over a showWebA. (i) Either God can create a stone which He cannot lift, or He cannot create a stone which He cannot lift. (2) If God can create a stone which He cannot lift, then He is not … read easy 7WebGod is limited in his actions to his nature. God is all in all so your inability to pick up a large stone means he can create a stone too large to lift. The fact that the stone is on a planet flying through space also means God can lift it. If this is actually a conundrum the just assume he doesn’t have unlimited power. how to stop obsessing over a situation